Focus 3

Teachers

The Urban School Boards Initiative project participants agreed that good teachers are central to the goal of raising student achievement, and the most effective school boards align all their actions and practice with the goal of attracting, developing, and retaining teachers who know their subject matter and how to teach it. This means identifying and hiring the best possible teachers and providing ongoing professional development that is focused on improving learning and raising academic achievement for all students.

Urban school districts frequently have a difficult time filling teacher vacancies and often can't match the salaries or working conditions found in suburban school districts. In addition, teachers hired in urban schools are more likely than their counterparts in suburban and rural districts to be teaching out of their field and to have no teaching license or an emergency or temporary one. This situation is a significant challenge for school boards, one that in significant ways is constrained by factors beyond their control.

"We need a massive change in the way we teach. That means leadership, funds, and lots of professional development."
—Anne Hallett, Executive Director,
Cross City Campaign for Urban School Reform



Class size, the availability of appropriate resources, and related factors all have an impact on student achievement, but some research has shown that the most significant factor is teacher knowledge and expertise.

The National School Boards Foundation's poll asked both the urban public and urban board members how they perceive their school systems to be doing, and asked them to identify what they consider the most effective ways to improve learning. The poll showed that the public believes good teaching is a critical factor in education. One of the most highly ranked suggestions for improving urban schools, according to the public, is ongoing training for teachers. According to the study, school boards have less confidence in teacher training as a strategy for increasing student learning.

chart 1

chart 2

Hire Good Teachers

Project participants agreed that, since the quality of the teachers hired determines to a great extent the potential benefits that can be derived from professional development and from accountability systems, school boards first need to ensure that the best teachers are hired to work in their school systems. Important factors in attracting good candidates are clearly articulated values, standards, and policies that support the work of teachers—enforcing discipline, creating an environment of civility, and providing the necessary time, materials, and assistance for teachers to do their jobs. Of course, the salaries and benefits offered need to be competitive to attract strong candidates. It also is essential that everyone involved in the process of hiring teachers understand the needs and expectations for teaching professionals in urban schools, particularly in regard to teaching a diverse student body.

Provide Professional Development

After good teachers have been hired, investment in teacher learning is the primary policy lever that school boards have to raise student achievement. A central part of a school board's role is to ensure that teachers are ready to help all children learn. Genuine professional development should be an ongoing process that provides teachers with access to the knowledge, skills, resources, and the time for collaborative discussions focused on improving learning and teaching. One participant in the roundtable characterized appropriate and meaningful professional development as a way of living one's life as a professional embedded in a learning community.

"It is in the interest of school boars to provide professional development that builds the competence and confidence of those they need to delegate to."
—Kelly Butler, Executive Director,
Parents for Public Schools



When staff development and professional growth become an integral part of the structure of the school, teachers are able to connect meaningfully with colleagues during the day. Add-on workshops and training held after school are not nearly as effective. It may be helpful to look to the kinds of professional development associated with, for example, medical and aviation training, which include apprenticeships, mentoring, and performance-based assessment.

Ultimately, if school boards want to raise academic achievement for all students, there will have to be fundamental changes in the way schools teach. New strategies to reach increasingly diverse groups of students and valid assessments will have to be created if teachers, administrators, and school boards are to make appropriate decisions. This will require leadership, funding, and integrated, ongoing professional development.

Questions

  1. How do we know that our teachers possess knowledge and a variety of effective pedagogical skills in their subject areas so that they can accommodate different student learning needs?

  2. How do our teachers' qualifications compare with those of teachers in similar school systems or in systems that we would like to emulate?

  3. To raise the quality of teaching in our district, what actions do the school system and the school board need to take? What other changes will need to take place?

  4. Beyond workshops, what kinds of professional development opportunities are available to our teachers? Are they adequate?

  5. How are our teachers assigned within the system? For example, do we assign our new teachers or our most experienced teachers to the most challenging students and to the most challenging schools?

  6. Do teachers know the academic goals of our school system and were they involved in setting the goals? How do we know?

  7. Do teachers believe that they have adequate authority, time, resources, information, and tools to make decisions, design curriculum, and plan lessons?

  8. What mechanisms do we have to determine whether teachers are helping students achieve the district's academic goals?

Teachers as Learners.
New York City's Community School District #2 has made an art and a culture of professional development—and has consistently raised student achievement in the process.....
Click here to read full case study

Recommendations for Urban School Boards

 

Copyright © 1999 The National School Boards Foundation.
This report may be saved to disk, printed out for individual
use, or reproduced, provided this copyright notice remains
intact on each copy.